Farmington River Report 11/28/23: Andy and Ross officially deemed members of the frozen chosen

I haven’t done a winter lesson in years, which is too bad. Winter can be a great time to fish the Farmington, especially if you like walking into any hole you damn well please because no one else is fishing. OK, so it’s not always like that, but with Monday’s cold front coming through — the mercury dropped 13 degrees in a matter of 10 minutes — and Tuesday’s forecast for gusty winds and snow showers — anglers were few and far between.

We fished from 11am-3pm, a good winter window. The method was drop-shot nymphing under an indicator, two-fly dropper system. The first mark was a popular spot within the PTMA. We had it all to ourselves for a half hour, then two more anglers showed up. The four of us managed one take in an hour, so I made the decision to head up to Riverton, where we’d find lover flows (PTMA was about 500cfs, Riverton 250cfs) and warmer water.

We also had solitude. The angler fishing 100 yards downstream from us left after 20 minutes. We stuck two fish at the the first place, one on the first cast, but then the action slowed. With 45 minutes left in our session, we moved upstream a quarter mile. Both Andy and Ross connected here, too, but sadly both trout wriggled off. With ice in the guides and the sun falling farther below the tree line, we called it a day.

Both Andy and Ross made significant, noticeable improvements over the course of the session, from casting to presentation. Lessons that bear repeating: it’s a bunch of little things that draw the line between fishing and catching. Drag-free drifts, false positives that let us know our flies are on the bottom, line management and mends, and especially looking for a reason to set the hook on every drift are all crucial to success. Well done, Andy and Ross!

I was so into the teaching thing that I didn’t get any shots of the lads in action. Here’s a sample of some of the bugs were were using.

Finally, a reminder that I do guide year-round. If you want to take advantage of reduced angler traffic, a winter lesson — it really is a different game than spring-fall-summer — will start you on the way.

3 comments on “Farmington River Report 11/28/23: Andy and Ross officially deemed members of the frozen chosen

  1. Brian Hoover's avatar Brian Hoover says:

    Steve, I know you mentioned in the Orvis podcast that you typically do not fish soft hackles during the late fall and winter months. But when you do fish them during the colder months, what patterns do you think would be ones to use?

    • Steve Culton's avatar Steve Culton says:

      I do fish soft hackles 12 months a year; however, I rarely swing them with a traditional wet fly presentation in winter. A most recent exception would be the time a few years ago in early December where there were trout slashing at W/S Caddis near the surface. A two-fly team, soft-hackle pheasant tail sz 18, did the job nicely. Most of the time, November through March, my soft hackle fishing is limited to dead drifting them as part of a nymph rig, most often as the top dropper. SHPTs, BHSHPTs, Starling and Herl, SH Zebra Midge — these are all good choices. Great question!

      • Brian Hoover's avatar Brian Hoover says:

        Thanks, Steve! I have included soft hackles as the top dropper of a euro nymph rig. But I’m going to do it more often. I also tie a fair number of CDC-collar nymphs.

        I have not (yet) tried a soft hackle midge…but definitely will now!

Leave a reply to Steve Culton Cancel reply