Q: When tying soft-hackled flies do you tie in the tip of the feather or the butt?
A: I’m almost always a tip guy. The stem of any feather is more flexible at the tip, and therefore easier for me to wrap. Also, feathers like starling are quite fragile — when I try to grip the tip of a starling feather with my hackle pliers, I often break off feathers to the point of rage. We don’t like rage when we’re tying. Maybe I just need to dial back the wrapping pressure. Or quit lifting weights.
Tying in by the tip is neither right nor wrong. It’s just the way I like to do it. I originally learned from Dave Hughes’ book Wet Flies, and he advocates tying in by the butt. I tried it that way, then tried it this way, and here we are. I encourage you to do the same in your tying and fishing: try different methods and pick the one that suits you. If I am tying a pattern like Stewart’s Black Spider, where I am starting at the head then winding the hackle rearward along the body, I will tie the feather in by the butt. This results in a tapered flow of hackle from large in front to small in back.
These hackles were all tied in by the tip. They look OK to me, and the trout certainly like them. So I must be doing something right.
Great information, Steve. I’m working on adding soft hackles to my box, specifically BWO at the moment. I think I’ve got these chickens figured out now, and I need a hen cape for my hackles….but is there a particular brand or style you prefer when using hen?
Thank you for sharing all this great information on your blog!
-Robert
Hi Bob,
Thanks for the kind words, and you are very welcome. I’ve been using Whiting Hen Capes for years. Great range of feather sizes and far less expensive than dry fly hackle.
Steve